No Room For Choice

Chattisgarh State Govt Does Little To Help Victims Of Forced Labour
  • Ministry of Health and Family Welfare has written to all States reminding them that every person should be counselled about the different family planning options available after the massive protests over the death of 13 women who underwent the sterilisation procedure of tubectomy in Bilaspur district of Chhattisgarh last November,
  • The letter completely contradicts the Union government’s intent of achieving population stabilisation almost exclusively through sterilisation.
  • In a letter sent in October 2014 to 11 high-focus States, the Ministry had noted that the 2020 family planning goals had “underlined the importance of sterilisation” surgeries in these States.
  • Even the recently released draft National Health Policy 2015 highlights the “challenge” of population stabilisation in six of the 11 States.
  • In order to achieve the annual targets, the government recently increased the compensation given to women/men, motivators and doctors.
  • If the revised incentive given to motivators is Rs.200 for tubectomy and Rs.300 for vasectomy, the amount is as high as Rs.1,000 for a “permanent limiting method” (tubectomy or vasectomy) in the case of couples after up to two children.
  • The higher incentive earmarked for permanent limiting methods is another reason why more women will now end up on the operating table.
  • The government recently added a new component : post-partum sterilisation done soon after or within seven days of delivery.
  • This approach works to the government’s advantage as more women are opting for institutional delivery to avail of the cash incentive earmarked for it.
  • Given the government’s primary focus on permanent and irreversible family planning options, the question of counselling women on the different options and giving them full freedom to choose the best one, will at best remain on paper, and not in practice.
  • The proportion of tubectomies to total sterilisations has been around 95 per cent since 2005; nearly 4.5 million tubectomies have been performed each year since 2000.
  • With a high number of tubectomies conducted every year and in a camp-based approach, tubectomy-related deaths as a result of poor quality of care will be inevitable even when they are done in health-care facilities.